Anti-Matter Costs for Space Travel |
Antimatter Production for Near-term Propulsion Applications (Link to PDF)
By G.R. Schmidt, H.P.Gerrish, J.J. Martin, G.A. Smith and K.J. Meyer
The conversion of input energy into the rest mass energy of the antimatter can be expressed via the following equation:
η = Eout / Ein
Where:
η: Conversion Efficiency of the process.
Eout: Rest Mass Energy of the collected anti-matter. (1.79 x 1014 Joules for one gram)
Ein: Energy placed into antimatter production plant.
NOTES: A perfectly efficient antimatter production process (which is a practical impossibility, like 100% efficient energy conversion) would have a η of 0.5 due to the fact that in order to create an anti-proton, you have to create its standard particle counterpart.
Present Day production facilities with an acceleration energy of 120 GeV and a collection ratio of 1:100,000 exist at such places as Fermilab and CERN. They have a overall η of 4 x 10-8 with a 50% wall plug efficiency factor. Producing one gram of anti-protons would require 4.5 x 1021 Joules – or 1.25 million terawatt hours (1,250 PW/h).
Near-Future production facilities with an acceleration energy of 200 GeV and a collection ratio of 1:20 are thought possible by NASA. They would have a overall η of 10-4 with a 50% wall plug efficiency factor. Producing one gram of anti-protons would require 1.78 x 1018 Joules – or 494 terawatt hours.
Far Future production facilities with an overall η of 10-2 would require only 1.78 x 1016 Joules, which breaks down as 4,944 gigawatt/hours or 4.94 terawatt/hours.
Magi-Tech production facilities with an overall η of 0.49 like Star Trek's antimatter production plants which simply “flip” normal protons into antiprotons via woo-tech would require merely 3.65 x 1014 Joules, which breaks down to merely 101.4~ gigawatt/hours.
To help clarify some of these numbers, here are some real world examples:
2008 World Power Generation (Complete): 19,103~ terawatt-hours.
2009 U.S. Power Generation (Complete): 3,953 terawatt-hours.
2009 U.S. Power Generation (Nuclear Only): 798~ terawatt-hours.
Slow Interstellar Exploration: (4.5 Light Years in 40 years – 30,000 km/sec delta V)
Single Stage Antimatter Beamed Core Rocket (80,000 km/sec ev): 51 metric tons of dry mass and payload, plus 24 metric tons of antimatter for an all up launch weight of 75 metric tons. 4.27 x 1023 J of energy needed.
Fast Interstellar Exploration: (4.5 Light Years in 10 years – 120,000 km/sec delta V)
Single Stage Antimatter Beamed Core Rocket (80,000 km/sec exhaust velocity): 51 metric tons of dry mass and payload, plus 179 metric tons of antimatter for an all up launch weight of 230 metric tons. 3.19 x 1024 J of energy needed.